Writing craft
How to Start a Story With Three Opening Examples
Learn how to start a story with three openings for the same scene, a worked revision, and a practical checklist for your first paragraph and first scene.
On this page
To start a story, put someone in a particular situation, give them something to want, and let a detail, interruption, or choice make the next moment matter. Your first sentence can be quiet. It needs to give the reader a way into the story and a reason to read the sentence after it.
Begin with a scene you can write now. You can find the final opening after you know what the story becomes.
If you are still choosing what to write about, start with these 40 short story ideas, which include three examples of turning a premise into scenes and a first passage.
Below, three original openings use the same fictional situation. You will see what each version emphasizes, how to carry it into a scene, and how to revise a paragraph that explains too much before anything happens.
Choose where the first scene begins
Write a plain sentence about the moment you want to enter: Someone is trying to do something, but something makes it difficult. This is a drafting aid, not a sentence you have to put in the story.
For our example:
Ada and her brother Ben are clearing their late mother's bakery before the buyer arrives at nine. A regular customer comes to collect a birthday cake their mother promised before she died.
Keep a few facts steady while trying different openings:
- Their mother died six weeks ago, and the bakery is now closed.
- Ada has agreed to hand over her key. Ben wants the sale to go through.
- At twenty to nine, Mrs Vale arrives with a receipt for an eightieth-birthday cake.
- The order is in their mother's book, but no cake has been made.
Ada's immediate task is to finish clearing the shop. The customer's arrival gives her a reason to reconsider it. Each opening below enters that situation at a slightly different moment. These are alternatives, not three consecutive passages.
If you cannot name an immediate task, use the character profile worksheet to connect a want to a possible action. You do not need the character's whole life history before trying a scene.
Three ways to open the same story
Start with an action that interrupts a plan
Ada had one hand on the bakery shutter when Mrs Vale ducked beneath it. “Chocolate, with the little roses,” she said, setting a receipt on the bare counter. Behind Ada, Ben checked his watch. The buyer would be here at nine. Ada opened the order book. Her mother's rounded handwriting filled the top line: Mrs Vale. Eightieth birthday.
The action is small: someone prevents the shop from closing. The shutter, receipt, and watch give the reader a place, a problem, and a time limit. The order book makes the request harder to dismiss.
What will Ada do about the order? The paragraph leaves that question open. It also leaves out her mother's death, a fact to supply soon so the reader understands why a familiar order is painful.
Action does not have to mean danger or a chase. It can be a person returning a key, refusing to sit down, or interrupting a routine. Choose an action that changes what someone can do next.
Start with dialogue that exposes a disagreement
“Please tell me you haven't promised her a cake,” Ben said.
“I haven't promised her anything.”
Mrs Vale waited on the other side of the counter, her receipt folded along an old crease. Ada kept her finger on the matching entry in their mother's order book. In twenty minutes, the buyer would want the keys. Ben held out the box for the last cake tin.
Ben is trying to secure Ada's agreement. Ada answers his words while leaving her next action open. The cake tin gives their disagreement something physical to settle: pack it or keep it out.
The opening names Ben immediately and identifies Ada a few lines later. The counter and order book give the exchange a place. Readers can follow who is speaking and what they are responding to.
Use this approach when the relationship carries the scene. If the dialogue is only a way to recite background, begin elsewhere or give the speaker a reason to bring up that information. The natural dialogue guide explores requests, evasions, and distinct voices in more detail.
Start with a voice that gives ordinary details meaning
In six weeks, Ada had learned how much of a person could be priced by the shelf. Mixing bowls, twelve pounds. Cake tins, five. Her mother's order book went into the box she was keeping. Then Mrs Vale set a receipt on the counter, and Ada had to take the book out again.
Here the reader meets Ada through what she counts and what she refuses to sell. The price list suggests how clearing the shop feels to her. The customer's arrival then makes the object she wants to keep useful again.
This opening spends more space on Ada's experience and gives less immediate information about the sale. If you choose it, bring in Ben and the deadline as the scene develops. Its quieter pace creates room for grief, but the receipt still changes what Ada is doing.
You can open with a setting, memory, or observation in the same way. Help readers sense why this person notices it now.
Choose the opening that fits the story you want to tell
The action opening puts the unfinished order first. The dialogue opening puts the siblings' disagreement first. The quieter opening puts Ada's attachment to her mother first. Any of them could lead into the same events, but they invite the reader to pay attention to different things.
Try reading each version with the next paragraph. If a striking first line makes you spend the rest of the page explaining it, a simpler beginning may serve the scene better. Keep the opening whose tone and emphasis you can sustain.
Carry the first paragraph into a scene
Give the character something to do with the information the opening supplies.
For the bakery scene, a possible sequence is:
- Ada checks the receipt against the order book. Her mother did accept the order.
- Ben asks her to arrange a refund so they can finish clearing the shop.
- After Ada explains what has happened, Mrs Vale asks whether Ada could make the cake for later that afternoon.
- Ada has to answer in front of her brother, who is still holding the packing box.
The cake cannot be made before the buyer arrives in twenty minutes. Agreeing to make it creates another problem: Ada must ask for access to the kitchen or find somewhere else to bake. Refusing it creates a different scene, in which she has to explain that decision to Mrs Vale and live with her own response.
The exchange changes the situation. A commitment, refusal, discovery, or question gives the next scene something to develop.
If the opening feels lively but nothing follows, use the stuck-scene diagnosis to check the goal, resistance, or consequence before polishing the first sentence again.
Revise an opening that explains too much
An early draft often records what the writer needs to understand. That material can help you discover the story even when it does not belong at the beginning.
An explanatory draft:
Ada was sad and conflicted about selling the bakery because her mother had died six weeks earlier. The shop had been a big part of her life. Her brother Ben thought that selling it was the sensible thing to do. Ada had agreed, but now that the buyer was coming at nine, she wasn't sure. A customer came in wanting a birthday cake that their mother had promised to make.
The facts are useful. The paragraph also names the feelings and summarizes both sides of the disagreement before the reader sees a specific moment. For a story that wants to stay close to Ada's decision, try moving some of that explanation into what she handles and says.
One possible revision:
Ben held the packing box while Ada lifted the last cake tin from its hook. Mrs Vale's receipt lay open beside their mother's order book: chocolate, with the little roses. Six weeks after her mother's death, someone still expected a cake. Ada set the tin on the counter.
“The buyer's here at nine,” Ben said.
“I know.” She turned the tin upright.
This version begins a little later in the scene, after Mrs Vale has presented the receipt. It keeps the death, the sale deadline, and the unfinished order while placing the siblings around an object they must either pack or use.
Notice four choices in the revision:
- The abstract conflict becomes an action. Ada puts the tin on the counter instead of in the box. The reader can interpret her hesitation through that interruption.
- One direct statement stays. “Six weeks after her mother's death” supplies context that gestures alone cannot make clear. You do not need to hide essential facts to create interest.
- Ben's line has an immediate purpose. He reminds Ada of their deadline. It does not establish everything he believes about the shop or the sale.
- The paragraph leaves a response to write. Ben can challenge her, Mrs Vale can speak, or Ada can make a proposal. Turning the tin upright suggests an intention without completing the decision.
The revision also loses the direct statement that the shop was a big part of Ada's life. If that history matters here, bring back a specific memory or a clear sentence. The show, don't tell exercises offer more practice choosing between action and direct explanation.
Give enough context without explaining everything
By the end of the opening passage, readers need enough information to understand the current situation. They can wait longer for the history of it.
In the bakery example, the reader soon needs to know that the mother has died, the cake was ordered earlier, and the siblings intend to hand over the shop. Without those facts, the customer may seem unreasonable and Ada's hesitation may seem arbitrary. The mother's childhood, the bakery's finances, and the siblings' earlier arguments can wait until they affect the exchange.
Separate a question you want the reader to consider from information they need to follow the scene. “Will Ada take on the order?” gives the scene direction. “Who are these people, and why is no one baking?” may simply mean that you have held back too much context.
In fantasy or science fiction, explain a world rule when it changes what a character can do. If a door opens only for someone who tells the truth, the reader needs that rule when the character tries to enter. The door's history can arrive later.
Try an opening exercise in twenty minutes
Use your own story, or borrow the bakery situation for practice. The timings below are just a way to keep the exercise moving.
- For three minutes, name the situation. Write who is present, what one person wants now, what interrupts them, and three facts each version must preserve.
- For nine minutes, try three openings. Spend roughly three minutes each on action, dialogue, and a viewpoint detail. Aim for a paragraph per version; leave sentences rough if needed.
- For five minutes, continue one version. Write a reply or action that makes the situation change. Let this test which beginning gives you somewhere to go.
- For three minutes, compare. Keep the version that best supports the scene's tone and next event. Save a useful line from another version without forcing it into the opening.
If you only have time for one paragraph, write the most concrete moment you can picture. Decide where it belongs later.
Check your first page
Read the page once for the reader's experience, then once for anything that needs clarification.
- Person: Whose experience or voice gives the opening its focus?
- Situation: Can the reader picture enough of the place and activity to follow what happens?
- Interest: What detail, desire, question, or disturbance makes the next sentence worth reading?
- Context: Have you given the facts needed to understand the present moment?
- Movement: Does someone respond, discover something, or make a choice?
- Expectation: Does the tone of the opening fit the story that follows?
These questions apply to the whole passage. A deliberate, reflective opening can take its time if the detail and rhythm sustain the experience you want.
Ask for focused feedback on an opening
Keep a copy of the original and name the effect you want to improve: clearer orientation, more pressure between two speakers, or less explanation before the first event.
If you use AI, ask it to diagnose a specific problem before requesting a rewrite. For example:
Read this opening and the paragraph after it. Tell me what a reader can establish, what they are likely to wonder, and where missing context makes the scene hard to follow. Quote the words that support your observations. Preserve the viewpoint, established facts, and quiet tone. Suggest one small change, but do not edit files yet.
Check the feedback against your intentions. A suggestion to make every opening faster or more dramatic may work against a story built around patience, intimacy, or uncertainty.
In GeekArt, keep the opening beside the relevant story notes, give a specific direction for the passage, and review the marked changes before deciding what stays. The annotation and revision guide explains that workflow. Your final check is to read the kept paragraph with what comes next.
Questions about starting a story
Can a story start with dialogue?
Yes. Give the line a purpose and establish the speaker and situation soon enough for the reader to follow. Ben's question in the bakery example works because Ada's answer can change what happens next.
Does a story have to start with action?
No. A distinctive voice, observation, or memory can hold attention. If you begin in reflection, look for a natural connection to the situation the reader will enter.
Should I begin with backstory or a prologue?
Begin there if the earlier material creates an experience the reader needs before the main scene. Try removing it: does the opening lose meaning, or can the information arrive later? A prologue should earn its place as a scene or passage in its own right.
What if I cannot find a good first sentence?
Write the next moment you can picture, with a plain placeholder if needed: “Ada is packing the bakery when a customer arrives.” Draft the exchange, then return to the beginning. The first sentence you write does not have to be the first sentence a reader sees.